The ‘facts’ are all contested or inconclusive, you are going to have to decide for yourself!


This constant banging on about people wanting ‘facts’ upon which to decide on the EU referendum is driving me crazy.

All the ‘facts’ are contested and those that aren’t are inconclusive.
As always in politics we are each of us going to have make a judgement based on our experience and values.

Calls for ‘facts’ are an attempt to avoid having to make such a judgement, the idea being that the ‘facts’ will determine that only one choice is rational. But this is rarely the case in politics or indeed economics, as the meaning of ‘facts’ always has to be interpreted, especially if they are being used to ‘predict’ future outcomes.

So having examined the facts to the extent I have been able, I have concluded the following:

1./ The EU is a profoundly undemocratic instrument of global neoliberal capitalism.
2./ The EU political project of federalising Europe has been pursued surreptitiously and bureaucratically and is not a project I support because I think a federal Europe is both politically undesirable and democratically unachievable.
3./ The EU is probably beyond ‘reform’ and will probably need to disintegrate before an alternative economic EU can be rebuilt.
4./ That disintegration could be initiated by Brexit.

Thus clearly I will be voting Brexit? Except I won’t. Why?

Because the referendum is taking place with neoliberal hegemony in the UK still in place. The right-wing Brexiteers are arguing that the EU is not neoliberal enough and a referendum vote for Brexit would mark a massive leap to the right in UK politics and in the short-term would almost certainly rapidly accelerate the dismantling of the NHS and the welfare state and the removal of workers rights.
For the first time in 35 years there is a possibility that the global neoliberal hegemony in the West is fragmenting. We could be living in a transitional era. We could be seeing the beginning of the post-Neoliberal age. The next UK election could be as important as the election of Thatcher in 1979 that began the Neoliberal era.

A vote for Brexit and a triumph for the right in UK politics will be a huge step backwards and possibly postpone the end of Neoliberal hegemony in the UK by ten years.

So, like Paul Mason, I will be voting to remain, not because I believe in the EU, I don’t, but because to vote for Brexit now would be to hand the far-right in the UK a victory that would be a significant set back for the progressive anti-austerity agenda.

Advertisements

5 responses to “The ‘facts’ are all contested or inconclusive, you are going to have to decide for yourself!

  1. Simon Davison

    Yes, I agree – except I think the EU is reformable – and that is quite important if you’re voting in.

  2. Well, no, actually Simon. My point is that even though I do NOT believe the EU is reformable this is not the time and these are not the circumstances to vote Brexit because of the short-term effect it will have on UK politics.

    Ultimately, I’m afraid think the EU as it is currently constituted is a malevolent institution that is fortunately doomed to failure.

    I think possibly within the next 12-24 months, but certainly within the next 5 years, there will be a major crisis in the EU as the EU zone collapses in on itself and the only way for Greece, Ireland, Portugal, Italy and Spain to survive will be to leave the Euro zone and thus have the ability to devalue their currency against the Euro (otherwise known as the Deutschmark). The collapse of the Eurozone will reveal the dominance of Germany and lead to the collapse of the EU.

    If I am wrong and the EU were to survive I would advocate Brexit but on a leftist agenda and under a leftist government.

    I oppose the political project of a ‘United States of Europe’ because it is both undesirable and democratically unachievable.

    Undesirable, because history shows us that the more remote government becomes from the local the more unaccountable and the more dangerous it becomes. Unachievable, because the peoples of Europe will NEVER consciously vote for a Federal European Government and so it will HAVE to be imposed surreptitiously – as it has been for the last 20 years. This is profoundly undemocratic and has resulted in profoundly undemocratic institutions fulfilling their unstated purpose almost in secret.

  3. Stephen D. Summitt

    Be independent, run your own show, vote Brexit

  4. Steve Summitt

    Now don’t fall victim to knee-jerk reactions. Don’t worry about what UKIP and I think. Do what’s right – vote Brexit. Keep UK free. (Thanks for addressing me as Steve and not Stephen (“Stefan”))

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s